By Jamie Cater, Senior Policy Manager for Employment and Skills at Make UK
Alan Milburn’s long-awaited report into young people and work calls for a welcome ‘system reset’ to help businesses employ young people.
The report - which publishes on the day that UK hiring falls to its lowest level in more than a decade - rightly recognises that helping young people into work means supporting businesses to create opportunities.
Rising business costs, regulatory pressures and uncertainty are affecting recruitment across the labour market. Addressing these barriers will help manufacturers invest in young people while supporting recruitment more widely.
From the outset of Milburn’s review, Make UK has called for action to address employment costs, improve apprenticeship funding and reduce labour market regulation. The report reflects these three priorities.
Future policy in these areas will be subject to what Milburn calls a ‘Youth Opportunity Test’, and the report sets out how this should guide the Government towards achieving those goals.
Addressing employment costs and creating jobs
The most important area for Milburn’s ‘test’ is on employment costs, where it is correctly acknowledged that while minimum wage and tax increases are not the root cause of the current challenge, these costs are constraining employers’ ability and willingness to hire young people.
In our submission to the review – as well as directly with the Government and Low Pay Commission – Make UK called for a pause on reducing eligibility for the National Living Wage to 18. It is welcome that the report urges the Government to make future decisions based on impact on youth employment prospects.
We will continue to argue that retaining employer discretion over youth rates, and proportionate minimum wage increases more widely, will preserve opportunities for younger workers.
The call for an increase in employer NICs relief for younger workers – building on the existing exemption for under-21s – is a welcome, practical step towards making recruitment more affordable and should be taken seriously by the Treasury.
The report recognises both the case for gradual introduction and the value businesses place on long-term certainty. Building on this with a clear plan towards full relief for under-25s in this parliament would give employers greater confidence to invest.
The report also reflects the concerns that Make UK has raised with the Government on the proposed ‘right to guaranteed hours’ – the measure which will limit the use of zero-hours contracts – that removing employer flexibility risks fewer jobs created.
Milburn is right to recognise that the Government should approach this reform with caution and preserve flexible, seasonal and temporary work which can be useful entry points for young people into work. We urge the Government to reflect this in final decisions on guaranteed hours measures.
Getting more young people into apprenticeships
Manufacturing businesses across the country have been built on the foundations of skilled workers who have learned their trade through an apprenticeship, and ensuring the same opportunity is available to this and future generations is key to the longevity of our industry.
The report makes one critical recommendation, called for by Make UK’s Industrial Strategy Skills Commission nearly two years ago and reiterated in our submission to the review – that every pound raised from the Growth and Skills Levy should go into the apprenticeship programme.
Before the end of this decade, it is forecast that the Treasury will keep hold of over £1 billion raised from businesses via the levy instead of this going towards apprenticeships for young people, while spending on apprenticeships is currently due to decline. Milburn fully echoes our view that this is wrong and cannot continue.
Increased incentives for hiring and training would help employers offer more opportunities. To maximise their impact, additional funding should also address the underlying employment and training costs that limit manufacturers’ capacity to take on apprentices.
Better funding for entry-level apprenticeship routes, alongside action on employment costs, would help turn the review’s ambitions into more places for young people. As Ministers consider changes to funding for older workers, the focus should be on expanding opportunities overall: supporting youth recruitment while preserving the high-quality training routes manufacturers need across their workforce.
Time for action
Manufacturers want to play their part in tackling the NEETs crisis, but creating more opportunities for young people requires Government and industry to work together.
After a year of work, Alan Milburn's report provides a welcome blueprint for that partnership: employment policy that supports recruitment and apprenticeship funding that unlocks additional places, while preserving high-quality opportunities across the workforce.
Make UK is ready to work alongside Government and industry to turn these recommendations into lasting opportunities for young people.